← Back to Bitcoin Improvement Proposals
BIPinformationallightningscript

Reject 199 (expired)

This BIP is expired according to BIP-0002 expiration rules. It is linking an ZKCP implementation (pay-to-sudoku). But ZKCP is [broken](http://stevengoldfeder.com/papers/ZKCSP.pdf). It is not mentioned that PTLC's are superior for many applications. The HTLC's are discussed and explained in the lightning-rfc documents, and they are subtly different. It is not explained how an optimal construction can be achieved using miniscript. Tagging @ebfull

2ack
ysangkok·Updated Apr 21, 2025·2 reviews·0 attestations·View source
Collections:BIPs — Rejected

Specification

This BIP is expired according to BIP-0002 expiration rules.

It is linking an ZKCP implementation (pay-to-sudoku). But ZKCP is broken.

It is not mentioned that PTLC's are superior for many applications.

The HTLC's are discussed and explained in the lightning-rfc documents, and they are subtly different.

It is not explained how an optimal construction can be achieved using miniscript.

Tagging @ebfull

Discussion (0 threads)

Loading discussions...